Latest Video: FilmCrunch 067: Hairspray, Chuck & Larry, Premonition reviewed
Veronica Santiago and Neil Estep review Hairspray, Chuck & Larry, and Premonition in this episode of FilmCrunch.Play Video
Tuesday March 6, 2007 8:00 am
Is Tyra Banks a Sociopath?
Posted by Andru Edwards Categories: Daytime, Talk Shows, America's Next Top Model, Talent, Editorial, Features
I’m not a psychologist or a psychiatrist; my training in that department goes only up to and including my Psych 101 class freshman year at Cornell. I’m just somebody who watches a bunch of TV, and watches clip shows like “The Soup” which boils down even more TV for me. All this having been said however, let me say this: I think Tyra Banks is a sociopath.
That’s not a value judgment at all. I guess it’s not technically a mental health judgment either because of my aforementioned lack of psychological training. But here’s the thing: I’ve been watching Top Model for a few seasons now, I’ve seen many clips of her talk show (I tried sitting through a whole episode and I just … yeah, no), and something’s always bothered me about Ty Ty Baby and I could never quite put my finger on it. Finally, though, when I saw Tyra salute herself on her talk show for being a trailblazer in African-American history (she was the first person of color to appear as the cover girl on the Sports Illustrated Swimsuit Edition), it all came to me.
She’s not just a narcissist; Tyra Banks has absolutely no sense of empathy. Having no ability to empathize is what (many websites tell me) catapults someone from simple narcissism to sociopathy.
I’m not saying that Tyra’s going to go out and do something awful (other than her talk show, boom, rim shot!) to anybody. She’s not dangerous at all. In fact, what I am saying, is that all of the behavior that people chalk up to a variety of unflattering causes, well, it’s not Tyra’s fault.
Why do I think Tyra has no empathy? Well, for example, she often does rating stunts on her talk show wherein she’ll dress up as somebody she’s not (homeless person, stripper, a man) and she’ll be utterly astounded at how this new character she’s portraying sees the world. I mean, the closest I’ve ever been to being homeless is being locked out of my apartment for a few hours, but if you asked me whether or not being homeless sucks, I would vote yes. I can imagine how degrading it must be to beg for food, how difficult it must be to live on the streets or even in shelters, and how heart-wrenching it must be to have your world turned upside down and live by a whole new set of rules.
But T. Banks? She can’t imagine it. When she pretended to be homeless for a day (seriously, a day), she was utterly astounded by the whole experience. In other words, until she actually experienced homelessness, it wasn’t real for her. By the way, the best part about the Tyra homeless adventure is that it occurred to her to do this after Will Smith invited her to a private screening of “The Pursuit of Happyness.” I find that when I’m invited to screenings of films by Hollywood A-Listers, my social consciousness barometer shoots right up too.
The dressing up as a man, the imitating (and ultimately chickening out as) a stripper, all of these things can be seen as ways to experience new things and, for the first time, understand them.
Plus, “America’s Next Top Model” can be seen as Tyra’s ginormous pseudo-empathy village. If Tyra has done something that the model/contestants are doing, and they react in a different way than Tyra did, Tyra is flummoxed. She can’t quite accept that somebody wouldn’t react the way that she did. In one of my favorite Tyra moments, she even transfers somebody else’s experience onto another model and … let me explain better.
Last season, the four remaining Top Model contestants all had to have their pictures taken in a very cold pool. When the models mention this, Tyra says that Sports Illustrated Swimsuit Edition models have had to do that lying in the snow. Then she tacks on, “I didn’t do it, but the other models did.” Basically, she’s saying, “I saw people do something like this, so why are you complaining?”
Also, last season, Brooke, the youngest of the contestants, got kicked off the show on the day of her high school graduation. Brooke, understandably, says something to the effect of, “This sucks. I could have been at my high school graduation.” Tyra, in all her awesomeness, feels the need to tell Brooke about how many people would kill to be in her position right now. Because Tyra didn’t go through it, Tyra doesn’t understand it.
So, no, I don’t know if Tyra has really crossed the border between narcissist and sociopath (can we at least agree that she’s a narcissist? I mean, how many pictures of herself does she have to put up in every Top Model House to let me state that as fact?), but if she’s not over the line, she’s scarily close. The new season of ANTM started this past week; only time will tell.
- Related Tags:
- americas next top model, antm, celebrities, daytime, editorial, models, sociopath, talk shows, top model, tyra banks
Advertisement
Advertisement
FriendFeed Activity:
On FriendFeed, this post was liked by 0 people and commented 0 times.
• View this post on FriendFeedAdvertisement
© Gear Live Media, LLC. 2007 – User-posted content, unless source is quoted, is licensed under a Creative Commons Public Domain License. Gear Live graphics, logos, designs, page headers, button icons, videos, articles, blogs, forums, scripts and other service names are the trademarks of Gear Live Inc.

Digg This















Comments:
Sadly, the problem you ascribe to Tyra is widespread in American culture, and is especially prevalent both among the 3rd and 4th generation of rich folks (possibly Paris Hilton, tho who knows?) and those without the benefit of a good education.
Tyra made he living based on her looks, and so a certain lack of understanding is expected.
On the otherhand, to take advantage of her position to educate herself, and to rectify her possible blind spots is praise worthy.
Not many would bother to search out one’s blind spots in the first place.
Reply to this: comment
Seems like the comment system is slightly broken, and doesn’t allow proper posting after a preview in some web browsers
Here is the final cut of my full comment
...................
Sadly, the problem you ascribe to Tyra is widespread in American culture, and is especially prevalent both among the 3rd and 4th generation of rich folks (possibly Paris Hilton, tho who knows?) and those without the benefit of a good education.
Tyra has made her living based on her looks, and so a certain lack of understanding is expected, according to the stereotype.
On the otherhand, to take advantage of her position to educate herself, and to rectify her possible blind spots is praise worthy.
Not many would bother to search out one’s own blind spots in the first place, never mind try to correct them
Too many take too much joy in seeking out the blind spots of others.
Reply to this: comment
I don’t know where you are coming up with all of this,but Tyra Banks is a good hearted person.And I LOVE her shows I never miss them.She has helped me by telling the world she is 161 pounds and SO WHAT.I had my son a year ago and I hated my body for not going back to size 1 but hey I’m a size 3 SO WHAT.I love my body now and I thank her for speaking out!!!!!
Reply to this: comment
Lack of empathy does not always mean sociopathy - It can mean a kind of high functioning autism or aspergers - the inability to guess or understand that the thoughts of others are different than ones one - there are so many ranges on the spectrum sometimes (As Tony Attwood discusses) it goes undiagnosed in Girls because unlike boys who manifest it in counting, numbers etc… they become great “actors” to navigate the social system, just like some autistic guys will become great theatrical preformers but cannot function as well socially on one on one or highly personal ways (outside the “preforming” role) While this seems like Sociopathy it is not - I think the range of emotions she shows precludes this - she feels them, but you rightly point out they are all centered around herself, or if others because she relates them to her own experience or way of thinking. Her explosive temper when people do not act as she expects them to (and subsequent lack of real understanding why people would react)and her need for creating this kind of structure around the whole modelling game on her show could be another Aspie thing. Unlike people like Oprah, who has longtime best friend Gail, it doesnt seem like Tyra has longtime, deep friendships of this sort - but can navigate a lot of superficial ones - very Aspie. (Tony Attwood’s book on Aspergers syndrome opened my eyes to this) and I think he may have mentioned how some people mistake this for sociopathy - but aside from the explosive temper tantrums, yelling or pendantic thinking and need for having things certain ways (which can leave a family confused and hurt) there is no real malice involved - it is almost a childish way of being, so the inherent narcisism isnt that offensive I guess (unless you are the child of a person like this, or under the employment of etc..) people can have “dashes” of this, maybe thats what Tyra has - a dash.
Anyway, sorry for rambling, thats my two cents.
Reply to this: comment
My favorite is Tyra getting emotional at the thought of stripping ... as though her early career as an underwear and skimpy bathing suit model were that different. Ummm, Tyra, what do you think teenage boys all over America were doing with your SI photo? Or your VS catalogues? Hint: Not admiring your modeling “talent” (how these ‘supermodels’ have gone on trying to convince us how tough their jobs are and how much talent they must have is a mystery to me).
Also, I don’t know about the diagnosis of Tyra’s sociopathy, but what drives me nuts about her—and about a public that seems to be buying into her—is how dumbed down her show is. I mean, what is so lacking in Americans’ intellectual lives that they turn to a high school-educated model for advice on and insight into the nuances of personal and social life?
The other day I heard her say prostitution is now an “epidemic” ... she never quite got around to supporting this claim with any sources or statistics or comparative analysis to any other time in history ... but, no problem, she says it ... they play the foreboding music, and they show the clips of a couple scantily clad women on the boulevard (probably models) ... and there it is: Instand, unsubstantiated epidemic.
Please, if you are over the age of 12, realize Tyra is a quirky, cute model ... not a social scientist, not an intellectual ...
Reply to this: comment 1 reply
I know you posted this a while ago, but prostitution was and is actually becoming, if it isn’t already, an epidemic. This topic has been in the news and I’m sure you can find more information about it if you look. As far as Tyra, just because she is a model does not mean that she is unintelligent in every area of life except modeling, or that she is simply unintelligent in general. I know plenty of people who have their degrees from college and are not people who should be giving advice about life. It matters on one’s perspective of the world in relation to the topic of discussion and what values, morals, and beliefs those people have.
Reply to this: comment | thread
I think she does shows like the homeless one for example to show her viewers what people in that position go through on a daily basis. Lots of people don’t know what other people go through. You don’t fully know until you put yourself in their shoes. The episode where she went undercover as a fat person really opened my eyes. I always knew that there are people who make fun of fat folks but to see Tyra go undercover like that really made me see the extent to which people do it. It’s terrible. Tyra is a kind-hearted person and she does shows like this to increase public awareness. Furthermore, she loves to help people. In the homeless episode she helped a family financially and by even offering a job. As for posing in the cold on ANTM, swimsuits shots are usually done in the cold weather…a season before the swimsuits actually go on sale. She was just preparing them for the reality of the modelling industry. I watch ANTM a lot. She is extrememly kind to the girls and they love her.
Reply to this: comment
There are quite a few sociopaths in America and we have the highest amount compared to any other country. This has a lot to do with our society and how we praise independent attitudes more than others. I have been doing extensive research on sociopaths because I am trying to figure out why a certain family member has been acting a certain way and not taking responsibility for his actions, or rather being aware that he did anything wrong. He seems to fit the sociopath persona perfectly and we are trying to get him evaluated, but as you will find, it is difficult to do so because sociopaths can convince most people that nothing is wrong with them.
As pertaining to your theory about Tyra, I have seen ANTM and her talk show, as well as interviews on other talk shows and I don’t believe she is a sociopath from the information I have found. You mention some of her characteristics but they don’t explain how she can truly be a sociopath because most sociopaths would not do the type of things she has done to help people or get a better understanding of other people’s lives, unless there was a significant gain for her from it. In Tyra’s case, she would get some beneficial gain from it but because she could not handle being homeless for a day or doesn’t quite understand how amateur models don’t fight harder to get to where they need to be, does not mean that she doesn’t understand anyone’s point of view. I’m sure there are points of view and ways of life that baffle you, as well. In any case, I know that Tyra shows too much animation and emotion to fit the sociopath label. There are other characteristics that would disqualify her, as well, but to get a better understanding for yourself, check out the psychopathy checklist by Dr. Robert Hare. You can find it online.
I’m not a professional, myself, but my mom is a mental health professional, I have had experience with a sociopath (maybe even two… probably two but he hasn’t been diagnosed or evaluated, yet), and I have read many sources about sociopathy (which is also known as psychopathy, and sometimes antisocial personality disorder as mentioned in the DSM-IV), so this is how I come to my conclusion about Tyra. I hope that helps!
Reply to this: comment